Bishop Edward J. Weisenburger | Diocese of Tucson website

On May 17, 2024, the Bishops of the Arizona Catholic Conference issued a statement expressing their concern over the ongoing border situation. They emphasized the urgent need for a federal solution to address the challenges faced by vulnerable individuals and American communities.

The bishops pointed out that states and local communities along the US-Mexico border are bearing much of the burden due to federal government inaction. This has resulted in an overwhelming number of migrants seeking to cross the border and an unacceptable number of migrant deaths.

While acknowledging the good intentions of lawmakers attempting to address these issues, they expressed concerns about HCR 2060. They believe this legislation could have unforeseen negative consequences and do not see it as an appropriate solution.

Despite proponents arguing that HCR 2060 is primarily a border security bill, there is no language in it limiting enforcement to within state borders. The bishops fear that this could undermine community trust in police if local law enforcement officers throughout Arizona were to enforce it. They argue that public safety could be compromised if crime victims and witnesses become too afraid to report crimes. Additionally, they raised concerns about potential racial profiling and civil liberties violations, particularly against vulnerable populations.

The bishops emphasized their commitment to upholding the rights and dignity of every person, especially families seeking safety together. They also expressed disappointment at the lack of provisions preventing enforcement in places such as places of worship, schools, and healthcare institutions.

In conclusion, they called on the federal government to better manage national borders and provide comprehensive immigration reform. They suggested that proposals like HCR 2060 are unlikely to withstand legal challenges and do not represent an effective solution.

The statement was signed by Most Rev. John P. Dolan, Bishop of Phoenix; Most Rev. Edward J. Weisenburger, Bishop of Tucson; Most Rev. James S. Wall, Bishop of Gallup; and Most Rev. Eduardo Nevares, Auxiliary Bishop of Phoenix.